Comments: doing Easter

The dilemma of Doing Easter for a thinking believer now mostly boils down to the fact that way too much Penal Atonement Theory blocks the doors to understanding, not least to celebration.

This Aztec framing of the way that God saves us makes Yahweh equivalent to the Sun God, except that Yahweh of course is the real Sun God; therefore, Jesus is the Real Victim whose heart must be torn out so that only the suffering of the purest can appease the Real Wrathful Sun God.

Thank goodness that this is not just where the theological buck stops. Otherwise, the real and deep scandalon of the cross would be reduced to gruesome Disney Religion, indeed.

To get a start on another modern emerging view of just what sort of Atonement we give ourselves to participate in, in faith, see the link at:

I not only can understand this perspective on Atonement without becoming too nearly Aztec as a Christian believer, I can actually discern in my own daily lived experiences the sorts of ways that this newer understanding of Atonement/Reconcilitation actually works in modern human global life.

Since the modern world is every bit as violent in its own self-justifying ways as the crucifixions of the ancient Roman Empire were, we are hardly free from considering violence in connection with either our daily lives with one another, or how human violence affects our individual and collective relationship to God. It is just so nice to begin to discern some other way to approach Jesus' crucifixion, faithful to its Jewish roots in temple sacrifice, without having to conclude that God's answer to human violence is the best possible divine violence. (See essay at:

To the cross and the tomb, then, for these are indeed too much with us still, in modern daily life all around our planet. We face global violence, because we believers know that Easter morning awaits, and that the diligent women are coming towards us in this mysterious flow of sacred time, to tell us what we hardly dare to believe as we men conduct business as usual - in Penal Atonement Theories, our violence in doing justice can try to mirror God's perfect violence? No?

Well then, are we created to be divinely superior to these women who now return from the tomb? Shall the higher ones listen to the unconfirmed, unverified witness of the lower ones, just because some women report bearing messages from God?

Nevetheless, these women are meant by God to be our first Easter witnesses. Thank goodness, thank God. I shall at least have a listen. Maybe I will hear some good news for a change.

Posted by drdanfee at Tuesday, 11 April 2006 at 4:42pm BST

I live in Central America.

One of the Wonders of the World should be the processions of Samana Santa in Antigua, Guatemala (take a peek/search on the computer)...the churchs from most of the aldeas (suberbs) and the BIG churches in the Antigua (San Francisco el Grande is my favorite along with La Merced and Escuela de Cristo) have their special time/day to carry huge statues of Christ who is portrayed at various "stages of the cross" (depending on the day) on platforms of precious hardwoods weighing thousands of pounds and some of them require thousands of purple hooded boys/men to carry them in rotation (they pay for this honor as a act of humility) on 10 hour trips throughout the city ...Antigua is jammed with tens of thousands of visitors moving about the hundreds of authentic Spanish Colonial churchs, government buildings and private homes draped in swags of purple cloth (that changes to BLACK on Good Friday)...surviving/restored Spanish Colonial buildings with cobbled stone streets gridded outward from the Central Park and the old Cathedral. The atomosphere here is filled with fragrant blooming trees, walls climbing with boganvilla and other flowers. Incense is whafting non-stop and thousands of firecrackers are continously being set-off on these Summerlike days/nights...funeral music is played behind every platform by mournful sounding brass bands as they make their way swaying slowly down the streets...they pause only at the corners to engineer and change the carriers and then take the "turn" as they make the sharp right angles with their precious cargos of faith, art and tradition. At each block families and other groups/fraternities of people have created very large and beautiful sawdust/flower petal, bright colored "alfombras/rugs" in front of their homes/organizations on the street. Intricate patterns are "woven" through the rugs that actually look perfectly dazzling and stunning with their religious symbols and stylized animals from nature and folklore worked through the varied designs...every "alfombra" is different and everyone of them is destroyed as the procession trudges by/over them making their way down the narrow cobbled streets. These traditional, historical, remarkable, loving and moving acts of Christian pagent are alive in Antigua, Guatemala each day and night of Holy Week to encourage everyone to deeply remember and celebrate the Passion and Resurrection of Christ...when the platform bearing Christ returns to the church late at night He is awaited by hundreds of people standing in the nave and the procession returns home and enters the door of the church people fall to their knees in welcoming respect...the band plays on and it the spirtual experience leaves me with a feeling of Thanksgiving and well-being...there is not a jet airplane or a picture of a jet airplane anywhere in the Valley of Panchoy.

Posted by Leonardo Ricardo at Tuesday, 11 April 2006 at 5:36pm BST
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Please note that comments are limited to 400 words. Comments that are longer than 400 words will not be approved.

Cookies are used to remember your personal information between visits to the site. This information is stored on your computer and used to refill the text boxes on your next visit. Any cookie is deleted if you select 'No'. By ticking 'Yes' you agree to this use of a cookie by this site. No third-party cookies are used, and cookies are not used for analytical, advertising, or other purposes.