Comments: Moving Forward in Covenant

Perhaps I'm just a rancid old stuck-in-the-mud Anglo-Catholic, but the hype doesn't seem to match the reality on the ground here a few miles from the birthplace of Methodism. We've had 30 years of a 'pioneering scheme' for Anglican-Methodist ecumenism which completely failed to engage the enthusiasm of more than a few die-hards, delivered next to nothing and diverted attention from engaging with RCs and with other denominations because all felt we were 'doing ecumenism'.

Advertising a service as 'Joint Anglican/Methodist' seems to have the effect of reducing attendance. Our joint deanery/circuit meetings seem to be about having an hour of anodyne 'Polyfilla' input so as not to upset anyone. Maybe this is just Typical Apathetic Lincolnshire - but are there any genuine positive stories out there? Other than the artfully spun ones?

Posted by david rowett at Thursday, 16 June 2011 at 1:00pm BST

The key to this is the ministry aspect mentioned: spreading around and reorganising ministers across many (often very many) churches. In the end the need for rationalisation, as Methodist numbers fall very rapidly, will simply cause the Methodists to merge back into the Church of England, if the Church of England can arrange a few Methodist-like services on a Sunday morning for a time period.

Posted by Pluralist at Thursday, 16 June 2011 at 3:23pm BST

It's good to hear that things are continuing to progress at the formal/institutional level. However, it's important to remember that the best work is done when churches work together to address needs in their communities, rather than 'doing ecumenism' as David Rowett puts it. Joint services had an important role when we were breaking down barriers of hostility and prejudice, but as my wife puts it we need fewer services and more service. Street Pastors, projects addressing homelessness and poverty are but two great examples of where we are "better together". If we get stuck thinking about joint worship, then anodyne polyfilla may well be our fate.

Posted by Mike Peatman at Thursday, 16 June 2011 at 3:57pm BST

"England and America are two countries separated by a common language." - George Bernard Shaw

Here I am, across the Pond, in the middle of the continent, and I read "polyfilla". It sounds vaguely Latin or Greek, vaguely religious, and I know that "poly" means "many", and "filla" looks like it could mean "sons or daughters", so I got this warm fuzzy feeling that there are many sons and daughters in the Body of Christ. Quite ecumenical.
Except it didn't seem to fit the context. So I looked it up in Google -- and laughed at myself.
Anodyne polyfilla can be found in many places, indeed!
Thank you, Messrs Rowett and Peatman

Posted by peterpi - Peter Gross at Thursday, 16 June 2011 at 6:59pm BST

I think this is good example of practical ecumenism, and the unity of these two great liberal Protestant communions is a good idea.

It further dilutes the attempt by Anglo catholics to pretend the Church of England stands in the Catholic tradition.

Like the inception of the Church of South India, it could make us a few more converts.

Posted by Robert ian Williams at Thursday, 16 June 2011 at 11:24pm BST

'it could make us a few more converts'

Sorry, RIW - I know you're bound by Apostolicæ Curæ, but we aren't (and the repeated moving of goalposts since AC by your hierarchs suggests that they don't really believe in its formulations either). Consequently, the sacraments are validly celebrated within the Anglican set-up, consequently there is no need to 'convert' on your hypothesis until the Anglican communion worldwide not only 'does a Jensen' but manages to kill off everyone like me.... Don't wait up!

Naturally you don't believe that, but since this isn't Vatican Radio, there's probably no great need for you to go into an explanation of why we're all wrong in the first place. I'm afraid I just don't accept your a prioris: if I did I'd have converted already.

Posted by david rowett at Friday, 17 June 2011 at 10:52am BST

"Like the inception of the Church of South India, it could make us a few more converts."

Who's/whose "us"?

Posted by JCF at Friday, 17 June 2011 at 7:30pm BST

Now that's an example of David Rowett infallibility.Thanks for your clarity.

Posted by Robert ian williams at Saturday, 18 June 2011 at 11:00pm BST

It could make us a few more converts"

Yes few is the word....despite the huffing and puffing the number that went over because of the South India scheme was miniscule ( see Michael Yelton's recent book published by the Anglo-Catholic History Society)..and a mixed bunch they were. You have netted a few more with the Ordinariate Robert...but again "few" is the word..and I suspect some of the laity will drift back ,as they did after 1993.

Posted by Perry Butler at Sunday, 19 June 2011 at 8:56am BST

"I suspect some of the laity will drift back ,as they did after 1993."

It wasn't only laity who drifted back after 1993......

Posted by david rowett at Wednesday, 22 June 2011 at 11:36am BST

During my youth in the 1960's in South Africa, a lot of work was done by young lay people at a local /parish level for worship and Fellowship between Methodists and Anglicans. Many Anglican clergy in my neighbourhood, did everything to stop any activities with the local Methodists,one even threatening me with ex-communication, resulting in many Anglicans leaving to join the Methodists.
With disillusioned Anglo catholics in the Cof E and other parts of the Communion leaving to 'cross the Tiber' into the Ordinariate, many will say that current efforts to bring the C of E and Methodists together is an effort to "save" the C of E. Not so.
The Wesley brothers were Anglican priests until their dying day.It was their followers who separated themselves from the C of E.
Take a look at any hymnal (even those used in Roman and Anglo catholic circles) and you'll see the contribution made to Christianity as a whole by these two individuals.
The Church worldwide is all the better for it.
In my own country, many Methodists worked towards the abolition of Apartheid together with Anglican, Roman catholic and other Christians.
Moving forward in a covenant which will hopefully bring Anglicans and Methodists together can only be welcomed.
After all, "The Church's One Foundation is Jesus Christ Her Lord"
Surely bringing God's people together is "Good News" in action, demonstarting that there is "On Lord, One faith , One Baptism, One God and Father of all..."
With the current demise within the Anglican Communion today, surely this development is something positive and should not be spurned by the cynics?
(Incidently, I'm from an Anglo catholic background, but Eccumenical at heart!)
God Bless you.
Fr Michael (Philippines)

Posted by Father Michael at Saturday, 9 July 2011 at 7:40am BST
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Please note that comments are limited to 400 words. Comments that are longer than 400 words will not be approved.

Cookies are used to remember your personal information between visits to the site. This information is stored on your computer and used to refill the text boxes on your next visit. Any cookie is deleted if you select 'No'. By ticking 'Yes' you agree to this use of a cookie by this site. No third-party cookies are used, and cookies are not used for analytical, advertising, or other purposes.